Managing Trade-Offs Between Program Objectives

Title page

What should a development program do when a promising way to raise farm incomes also threatens soil health? When priorities are left implicit, what gets measured and rewarded can determine which objectives take precedence. In the Canopy Lab’s working paper Managing Trade-offs Between Program Objectives, Andrew Panton sets out a four-step process to help donors and implementers make those choices deliberately. The paper shows how to agree which objectives take priority, where there is room to compromise and which limits must hold, then put those decisions into practice through program design, contracts and delivery and revisit the balance as evidence emerges.

Managing Trade-offs Between Program Objectives_Working Paper_261117

Maha Elhayek

Senior Consultant

I specialize in market systems development in fragile and conflict-affected settings. Over the past decade, I have advised programs across the MENA region, Africa, and Eastern Europe. My work spans agricultural and industrial sectors, focusing on market systems assessments, program design, and strategies that expand opportunities for marginalized groups and support gender mainstreaming. I enjoy applying systems thinking to uncover structural barriers, co-create locally grounded solutions, and advise on private sector partnerships. I am currently passionate about applying MSD approaches to address climate change challenges.

Andrew Panton

Environment and Climate Change Practice Lead

I am committed to improving human livelihoods and resilience in balance with nature. At the Canopy Lab, I provide research and advisory support to projects working on biodiversity conservation, climate change adaptation and resilience, nature-based solutions, sustainable tourism, and market systems development. Outside work, I’m a keen guitarist, cyclist and bookworm, with a love for food, travelling and learning languages.

JESSICA RUST-SMITH

Senior Consultant

I work across markets, business and supply chains, impact investing, agriculture, and women’s economic empowerment. I am an experienced monitoring, evaluation, research and learning consultant and project manager with expertise in the use of mixed methods, theory-based approaches and data collection and analysis. I have been working in M&E for market systems development for 10 years now, and going strong.